Peanut Butter Milkshake
A frozen milkshake made with whole milk, sweetened condensed milk, whipped topping, and melted smooth peanut butter, processed on the Milkshake setting. Rich, creamy, and indulgent with deep peanut butter flavor and a thick, velvety frozen texture. Non-alcoholic - no spirits required.
Instructions
- 1
Melt the smooth peanut butter first; combine whole milk, sweetened condensed milk, softened whipped topping, and melted peanut butter in a large pitcher and whisk until completely smooth.
- 2
Pour the mixture through the fill opening, keeping the level between the MIN and MAX fill lines; close the lid securely.
- 3
Select the Milkshake setting and power on the machine.
- 4
Allow the machine to run for 30–35 minutes; when the lights stop blinking and remain solid, the milkshake has reached proper thickness.
- 5
Pull the handle to dispense into glasses and serve immediately.
- 6
Tip: Melt the peanut butter before mixing - cold peanut butter creates clumps that won't blend properly into the milkshake.
Pro tips
- ▸Melt peanut butter before mixing - cold peanut butter leaves stringy bits.
Reviews
No written reviews captured for this recipe yet. See it on Simply Safe Eats ↗
Full recipe & photo credit
Simply Safe Eats
You might also like
Easy Chocolate Milkshake Slushi
A frozen chocolate milkshake made with whole milk, heavy cream, vanilla extract, granulated sugar, and chocolate syrup, processed on the Milkshake setting. Rich and sweet with a deep chocolate flavor and a thick, creamy consistency. Non-alcoholic - no spirits required.
Strawberry Milkshake Slushi
A frozen strawberry milkshake made with whole milk, heavy cream, vanilla extract, granulated sugar, and strawberry syrup, processed on the Milkshake setting. Sweet and fruity with a creamy dairy base and a light strawberry flavor throughout. Non-alcoholic - no spirits required.
Creamsicle Milkshake Slushi
A frozen creamsicle milkshake made with whole milk, heavy cream, orange juice, vanilla extract, and granulated sugar, processed on the Milkshake setting. Tastes like a classic orange cream bar - citrusy and bright with a smooth vanilla-dairy background. Non-alcoholic - no spirits required.